Two days later Sam and Dean catch wind on the death of Will Carlton who drowned in the sink and who is also the son of Bill Carlton and brother of Sophie Carlton, the girl who disappeared a few days earlier in the lake. After hearing about Will's death Sam decides to do some research on the lake and finds that a man with the last name of Barr drowned in the lake and his son Lucas was out in the boat for two hours until he was saved. They find Andrea and Lucas at the park so Dean heads over to Lucas to try to get him to tell him what's wrong and what he saw out in the lake the day his dad died but he wouldn't say anything. After getting nowhere with Lucas he walked back over to Sam and Andrea while Andrea was explaining to Sam that before her husband's death Lucas had such life in him and it was hard to keep up with him. Lucas walks up to Dean and hands him a picture that he drew of a house. Sam and Dean went off trying to find the house that Lucas drew and when they finally did they talked to the old lady that was living there.
A little boy her son Peter Sweeney use to live there but he suddenly went missing one day and the cops couldn't find him so they just stopped looking. He was suppose to ride his bike home from school but he never showed up. They find out that Peter was friends with Bill Carlton and Sheriff Devins. Sam and Dean decide to talk to Bill Carlton about Peter but they see him driving his boat out to the lake then suddenly a big force comes swooping up, pushing the boat into the air and killing Bill Carlton. They head over to the police department to talk to Sheriff Devins' about Bill Carlton's death and the Sheriff explains to them that he ran their badge numbers and they are not really Federal Marshells and told them if they didn't leave this town he would lock them up. Sam and Dean pretend to drive away but instead they head over to Andrea's house. Meanwhile Andrea is putting Lucas back into bed after he got out to draw pictures. She goes to the bathroom and turns on the bathtub and she gets in and closes her eyes.
While she's laying in the bathtub the water pouring out starts to turn brownish green then suddenly something pulls Andrea down into the water trying to drown her. Lucas is banging on the door trying to get in to help her but he couldn't so he runs down stairs and opens the door to Sam and Dean. They realize something is wrong so they run up and break into the bathroom and try to pull Andrea out of the tub. They finally pull Andrea out and it turns to morning and they sit down to ask her what happened. She tells them that while she was getting pulled down she could here someone say "come play with me." Dean goes up to Lucas' room to talk to him which is when he gives Dean another picture that he drew but this one was of a bike. They go outside behind the house and they feel something in the ground so they start digging up the grass and they pull out a big blue rusty bike. Sheriff Devins' walks up pointing a gun at them asking them how they knew that was there. Andrea runs out of the house trying to get her dad to stop and Dean forces him to tell everyone what happened to Peter
He was the smallest out of the three kids so they would always pick on him. One day they took it a little too far and they held his head down in the water, they held it too long that he drowned. The boys freaked cause they just killed their friend and they didn't know what to do so they let the body fall into the lake and they buried his bike. Sheriff Devins' explains to Andrea that they were just little kids and they didn't know any better and they never meant to kill him. Lucas runs out to the dock and kneels down and reaches his hand out to the water and Peter grabs Lucas' hand and pulls him into the lake. They all run after to save him and Sheriff Devins' gets into the lake yelling "I'm sorry, I'm sorry. Don't do this, he's just a little boy! Take me!!" After Sheriff Devins' rant Peter swims up and drags him under the lake where Sheriff Devins' meets his death. Dean jumps out of the water saving Lucas and he regains conciseness. Sam and Dean pack up and get ready to leave while Andrea and Lucas walk up with a plate of food for them. After this whole thing ends Lucas begins talking again so Dean tells him to say the most important thing of all which is....... "Led Zeppelin rules!!"
I think this have to be one of my favorite episodes of this season but I can't really explain why. I do like the whole creepy voice saying "come play with me" while their getting killed. You see Dean's softer side in this episode which he mainly likes to hide cause he doesn't want people know that he has a warm heart and he's just a bad ass mofo. Sam is just the same as he usually is wanting to keep looking for their dad blah blah blah nothing new. Sammie being Sammie. I give this episode 5 out of 5 Skulls. Don't forget, the next post will be my 100Th post so be sure to email me your questions you have for me so I can answer them on my post. For my 100Th Post Extravaganza I'll be telling 50 things about myself and I'll answer 50 questions about me you all have. I'm not too sure I'll be getting 50 questions from you guys since I only had one person email me their questions. So be sure to do that cause my next post will be my 100Th post and I don't want to post it until I get all of your questions. Email me your questions at firstname.lastname@example.org . If I don't receive 50 questions that's okay I'll just think of something else to put on my post. Have an fantastic freaky day!!